The Returning Room: a dim fictional apartment corridor and an open door

The Returning Room: An Original Horror Story

Original horror fiction. The Returning Room is a fictional short story created for Evil’s Eye. Its characters, building and events are invented.

The first thing I carried out of the flat was a brown chair with one short leg. I put it in the skip myself. When I came back for the carpet, the chair was standing in the bedroom again.

Its short leg had left a fresh groove through the dust.

Story sections

The clearance

The building had six flats. Five were already empty. I had until Friday to clear the last one, then a contractor would board the windows and disconnect the water.

There was nothing valuable inside: a chair, a blue cup, a narrow bed without a mattress. The letting agent gave me an inventory card and told me to photograph anything I couldn’t move. She didn’t come upstairs.

When I mentioned the chair, she asked whether someone had helped me.

“No.”

“Then you probably took it out of a different room.”

I wanted the invoice paid. I photographed the chair beside the skip, photographed the empty corner, and went home.

That night I woke with a small, ordinary worry. I had left my work gloves on the chair.

What the returning room kept

On Tuesday the chair was back. The gloves lay on its seat, fingers neatly straightened. The blue cup stood beside it. I had wrapped the cup in newspaper and dropped it into a bin on the landing.

I checked my photographs. There was the chair beside the skip. There was the bare corner. Both images carried Monday’s date.

I began calling it the returning room, partly because giving it a stupid name made it easier to walk into. I moved the cup into the kitchen and stood in the bedroom doorway.

For ten minutes nothing happened. A pipe clicked inside the wall. A van reversed somewhere outside.

Then my phone rang. I looked down, silenced it, and looked up.

The cup was beside the chair.

I hadn’t heard it land. It was positioned with its handle toward the seat, where a person’s right hand would reach.

The Returning Room: a lone wooden chair and blue cup in an empty bedroom
Original editorial artwork created for Evil’s Eye, inspired by The Returning Room, a fictional horror story. Not a real location photograph or documentary evidence.

Something borrowed

I should have left. Instead I decided that somebody was making a fool of me, and I wasn’t going to lose three days’ wages because I couldn’t work out how.

I put a coin under the chair’s short leg. It stopped rocking. Then I took the chair down two flights, locked it in my van, and returned with the keys in my fist.

The chair stood in its corner.

My van was still locked. Through the rear window I could see the blankets I’d folded over the chair to keep it from scratching the panels. They had collapsed around an empty space.

The coin had returned with it.

The returning room wasn’t putting things back where they belonged. It was deciding where they belonged.

That was the detail I couldn’t explain away. The chair and cup belonged to the flat. The coin belonged to me. I had given the room something, and now it was keeping that too.

I retrieved my coin. It felt warm. I turned it over, checking for a sticky pad, a magnet, anything, and noticed the edge of a photograph underneath the chair.

It showed my kitchen.

The inventory changes

Not a kitchen like mine. Mine. The split in the window blind. The cupboard that never closed. The mug I’d left beside the sink that morning.

The photograph had been taken from the doorway. Someone had stood where I stood every evening when I came home.

I called my sister and asked her to check the house. She lived two streets away. I stayed on the line while she opened the front door.

“Nobody here,” she said.

“The kitchen?”

“All fine. Why?”

I told her about a possible break-in. I couldn’t make myself describe the returning room while I stood inside it.

Then she asked what I’d done with the kitchen chair.

There should have been two. She could only see one.

I looked at the brown chair in the corner. Its back had changed. The blunt wooden spindles now had the shallow grooves I’d cut into mine when I used it to support a board.

My sister was still talking. I heard a cupboard close behind her.

Inside the flat, the same cupboard closed, somewhere beyond the bedroom wall.

I told her to get out of my house.

The Returning Room: an inventory card beneath a closed bedroom door
Original editorial artwork created for Evil’s Eye, inspired by The Returning Room, a fictional horror story. Not a real location photograph or documentary evidence.

The card under the door

The bedroom door shut before I reached it. There was no slam. The latch settled gently, as though someone on the other side had held the handle down until the door met the frame.

I pulled. The handle moved, but the door stayed closed.

My sister’s voice continued through the phone.

“I’m at the front door.”

I heard her turn the lock. At the same instant, a key turned outside the bedroom.

“Leave it,” I said. “Don’t touch anything. Just wait.”

A pale rectangle appeared beneath the door. Someone pushed my inventory card across the carpet.

I’d filled in three items that morning. Chair. Cup. Bed frame.

Now there were more, in my handwriting. Coin. Photograph. Kitchen chair.

Below them: one male occupant.

There was a small empty box beside each entry. I had used the boxes to mark things I’d carried out.

The first six had ticks. The last did not.

Behind me, the chair creaked. Not under a sudden weight. It creaked the way a chair does when someone who has been sitting very still finally moves a foot.

A final inspection

I stayed facing the door. I put my hand behind my back and felt for the chair. There was a trousered knee where its empty seat should have been.

The fabric was damp.

“Where are you?” my sister asked.

I could hear her twice now. Once through the phone, once through the bedroom door.

“Still at the building.”

“No,” she said. “I can see your shoes.”

I looked down. I was barefoot. My work shoes sat against the skirting board, toes pointing toward the door. One had a wet lace pressed against the leather.

The knee beneath my hand shifted. A hand closed around my wrist, with the light, patient grip of someone helping a stranger keep his balance.

Through the phone, my sister asked why I wouldn’t turn around.

I don’t remember letting it go. I heard it fall onto the carpet, and then I heard it fall again, much farther away.

There is no window here now. The door stays shut. Sometimes a thin light appears beneath it and I hear the scrape of something heavy in the corridor.

I keep the inventory card on my knee.

This morning, in the returning room, someone ticked the last box.

A little later, I heard my key in the front door. My sister said my name. Whoever answered had remembered to sound out of breath from the stairs.


About this story: This is original supernatural fiction, not a true account or witness testimony. The illustrations depict imagined settings. No real victim, address or reported haunting is represented.

For nonfiction that separates haunting legends from the surviving record, explore the Greenbrier Ghost murder trial and the history behind Waverly Hills Sanatorium.

For a separate collection of classic supernatural fiction, M. R. James’s Ghost Stories of an Antiquary is available through Wikisource.

Leave a Reply